Skip to content

What to Do with Old Baseball Cards

Frequently, we purchase boxes or packs of sports cards just for the purpose of flipping any of the hits that come out of them. In part, this aids in the recovery of a portion of the purchase price. After that, we divide the players and teams, leaving a large pile of commons from the basic set. As a result of the large number of items published each year, these sports card commons can quickly accrue and, if left unchecked, could swiftly develop into a hoarding situation within a few years. So, what should we do?

According to most collectors who have kept up with the hobby, there were far too many of these produced. Few were thrown out in order to elevate the worth of those that remained. They were purchased by everyone. They were saved by everyone. The card industry produced millions of them in order to keep up with demand. So now they’re just sitting there, starring at you in the eyes. Everybody from Ken Griffey Jr. to Frank Thomas to Juan Gonzalez to Mike Piazza to Kenny Lofton and everyone else. They were both excellent players. It appears that the rookie cards you stored in plastic cases and binders are still in the same condition as they were when they were first removed from the pack or the sports card shop owner’s case. Nonetheless, that once-cherished collection is now only worth about 1/100th of what they purchased for it in the first place.

What to Do With All That Junk If you’ve never lost your collecting gene, have purchased a lot since then, and have boxes upon boxes of commons and stagnated stars that will not fit into a set, you might be asking what the heck you should do with all of this garbage.

Here are some suggestions to help you declutter your closet, get your wife or significant other off your back, and perhaps, just maybe, accomplish the seemingly impossible: Find someone who is truly interested in them.

The Best Thing to Do With Your Old Baseball Cards

  • Make a donation in their honour.
  • They can be packaged up and given away as Halloween gifts.
  • Put them up for sale in a garage or yard sale.
  • Donate them to a charitable auction to help others.
  • Advertise them in your local newspaper or to your local shoppers.
  • Submit them to an online classified ad service.
  • Give them to a few of your neighbours.
  • Make use of them for your art endeavours.

What caused the decline of the baseball card market?

There were two elements that contributed to the collapse of the baseball card market in the late 1980s and early 1990s, and both of them entailed generating money on both sides of the transaction.

When people began to see an increase in the value of baseball cards, they realised they had discovered a method to get wealthy without exerting much work. Adults began “investing” in baseball cards, anticipating that the value of the cards would climb in the same manner as it did in the 1950s, rather than just enjoying pulling a card of their favourite player. It wasn’t taken into consideration, however, that the fact that those early cards were more valued was owing to a scarcity of cards in general. It wasn’t just moms who were getting rid of their children’s collections; manufacturers such as Topps were also destroying goods that was failing to sell since they didn’t want to store it themselves.

The flip side of this coin is that, as a result of the increase in purchasers, card companies such as Topps, Fleer, Donruss, and others saw an opportunity to basically manufacture their own money. The more the number of cards purchased, the greater the number of cards created. What was once limited to a print run of a few hundred thousand or fewer cards was now being produced in the millions by the card’s manufacturer.

The bubble burst when the “investors” discovered that their collection of cards no longer carried the perceived worth they had previously possessed because everyone else had the same collection of cards, all in immaculate condition. While cards from the early days were difficult to come by in mint condition due to the fact that children were allowed to play with them at the time, as well as the fact that the printing process was not always faultless, this was not the case any longer with modern cards. Due to the fact that everyone could find an exact duplicate of the card they desired, prices fell faster than the number of collections could be sold.

What is the best way to determine whether any of my old baseball cards are worth anything?

Normally, I wouldn’t bother to find out, but if you really want to, you can purchase price guides (the best of which is published by Beckett) that list most cards and their “value,” there are card shops that may be able to assist you, or check Ebay to see if anyone is selling any cards similar to yours. The first thing to know is that it doesn’t matter how much a book is worth in its own right; it is only worth what someone is prepared to pay to acquire it.